Denise Phua gets along well with foreign workers

Walking Time Bombs – No more

Screenshot 2016-04-08 16.50.06

Here’s her post.

I recently made a short speech under the MHA budget debate. The speech is appended here. I have no intention to undermine any specific group. I should not have used the phrase “walking time-bombs” to describe congregations of high density. 

I personally get along very well with the foreign cleaners in my constituency. To them and the other foreign workers in our country, thank you for your help and please accept my sincere apology if I have caused you concern. 

My MHA Speech:
“Mr Melvin Yong and I are the local Members of Parliaments taking care of the residents of Little India. We wish to speak on behalf of our residents to ensure that the Little India riot of December 2013 will not happen again. The riot being the worst public disorder in Singapore in more than 40 years.

We are thankful for the post-riot recommendations of the Committee of Inquiry (COI) regarding alcohol restrictions, beefing up of police operations and patrols and the decentralisation of crowds to recreation centres in the rest of Singapore. 

Recently, I was at Little India with Home Affairs Minister Shanmugam and members of the Police Force. It was obvious that the pre-riot crowds have returned to Little India. Madam, congregations of such high density are walking time-bombs and public disorder incidents waiting to happen. It is important that we do not take our eyes off this matter lest we want history to repeat itself. I hence wish to ask for Minister’s update of his plans in regard to this matter. I also ask for his favourable considerations of the following suggestions:

(1) Form a high-level multi-agency Task Force to mitigate the security and dis-amenity risks of high congestion of visitors to Little India;
(2) Ring-fence the Communal Areas of Residents such as the playgrounds and void decks so that the old and the young get to use the space meant for them;
(3) Continue with and do not stop resourcing the recommendations of the Committee of Inquiry viz-a-viz alcohol consumption restrictions and patrol teams;
(4) Decentralise further by building more recreation centres outside Little India; and
(5) Engage regularly through planned dialogues with all key stakeholders, the foreign workers, agents, businesses and residents.

The contributions of the foreign workers benefit our entire nation as they help build much of our nation’s infrastructure. We need them and we accept that foreign workers like the rest of us, have social and leisure needs amongst other needs. 

The issue is not a Little India locality issue. It is a national issue that can only be solved by carefully balancing the needs of all stakeholders – the workers, the residents, the businesses and the rest of Singapore.”

(End of speech)

So she has apologised for the loose use of the term “walking time bombs” and she’s explained that the term was meant to describe any congregation of high density.


However it’s still worrying when public figures, ministers no less are careless with their words.

Her suggestions to mitigate the crowded district of Little India however seem to be in tune to her original message of them being “Time Bombs”.

Ring fencing the area to contain them? Placing them in an enclosure so that it’s easier to contain them when or if a riot breaks isn’t exactly a wise choice. Indicating that there are boundaries for foreign workers to stay within would only incite more frustration and exclusion from society.

Placing more armed personnel on the ground would also seem like a negative way to encourage peace. We wouldn’t want anyone getting shot under any circumstances would we?

Let’s look at it frankly, Bringing in more security and fencing the area to keep foreign workers docile. That sounds like a Trump campaign right there.

Her intentions may have been for the best, her choice of words certainly failed to convey them. Perhaps hire a staff of writers to pen your words for you in future?



Zeen is a next generation WordPress theme. It’s powerful, beautifully designed and comes with everything you need to engage your visitors and increase conversions.