This could encourage passengers to tap the windows of private hire cars and ask for a ride.
If this happens, illegal street hails might become more common.
Street hails – a grey area for private hire drivers?
Some netizens commented that once Uber drivers have their decals displayed (from April 2017), they can pick up passengers as long as they are approached by commuters.
On Uber’s website, it is stated that “picking up passengers who have not requested through the app is both illegal and dangerous for both parties”.
This means that it still has to be an app booking.
Question. So if private hire drivers are plying on the roads and passengers hop into the car first before booking via the app, is this still considered a form of street hail?
It is and it is prohibited by law. The statute on prohibition on plying for hire on road, parking place or public stand reads:
(1) No person shall ply a private hire car or cause or permit such vehicle to be plied for hire or for the purpose of gain on any road or parking place or from a public stand.
Members in the Singapore Taxi Group also consider it as street hail.
28 out of 39 respondents who participated in a quick poll in the Facebook group agree that even if commuters hop into the private car before booking via app, it is considered a “passive street hire” or a “street hire with conditions”.
Why would drivers take the risk?
Mr Ang Hin Kee, Executive Adviser of the National Taxi Association (NTA), in an interview with momentum T, thinks that private hire drivers are resorting to illegal street pickups as they cannot earn enough by app bookings.
“Why would you (private hire drivers) do that (illegal street pickups)? If you are very busy making money from all these bookings, you don’t have to take the risk. You know it’s illegal and you take the risk.”
He explained how third party apps and car leasing companies entice private hire drivers to join them, through offering attractive salaries, allowing them to own a car and not having to deal with the rules and regulations which taxi drivers have.
“(Yet if a private hire driver thinks I have) not enough business, through the channel you (third party apps) promised me (private hire drivers) then I have to depend on this other option to make money.”
How will this affect taxi drivers?
There is a saying that goes…if you can’t beat them, join em.
Taxi drivers view third party apps as competition and threat to their livelihoods.